{ "schemaVersion": "1.0", "item": { "slug": "multi-viewpoint-debates", "name": "Multi-viewpoint Debates", "source": "tencent", "type": "skill", "category": "开发工具", "sourceUrl": "https://clawhub.ai/LatentFreedom/multi-viewpoint-debates", "canonicalUrl": "https://clawhub.ai/LatentFreedom/multi-viewpoint-debates", "targetPlatform": "OpenClaw" }, "install": { "downloadMode": "redirect", "downloadUrl": "/downloads/multi-viewpoint-debates", "sourceDownloadUrl": "https://wry-manatee-359.convex.site/api/v1/download?slug=multi-viewpoint-debates", "sourcePlatform": "tencent", "targetPlatform": "OpenClaw", "installMethod": "Manual import", "extraction": "Extract archive", "prerequisites": [ "OpenClaw" ], "packageFormat": "ZIP package", "includedAssets": [ "references/capitalist.md", "references/how-to-debate.md", "references/elon.md", "references/monkey.md", "scripts/run-debate.sh", "CLAWDHUB_FIRST.md" ], "primaryDoc": "SKILL.md", "quickSetup": [ "Download the package from Yavira.", "Extract the archive and review SKILL.md first.", "Import or place the package into your OpenClaw setup." ], "agentAssist": { "summary": "Hand the extracted package to your coding agent with a concrete install brief instead of figuring it out manually.", "steps": [ "Download the package from Yavira.", "Extract it into a folder your agent can access.", "Paste one of the prompts below and point your agent at the extracted folder." ], "prompts": [ { "label": "New install", "body": "I downloaded a skill package from Yavira. Read SKILL.md from the extracted folder and install it by following the included instructions. Tell me what you changed and call out any manual steps you could not complete." }, { "label": "Upgrade existing", "body": "I downloaded an updated skill package from Yavira. Read SKILL.md from the extracted folder, compare it with my current installation, and upgrade it while preserving any custom configuration unless the package docs explicitly say otherwise. Summarize what changed and any follow-up checks I should run." } ] }, "sourceHealth": { "source": "tencent", "status": "healthy", "reason": "direct_download_ok", "recommendedAction": "download", "checkedAt": "2026-04-30T16:55:25.780Z", "expiresAt": "2026-05-07T16:55:25.780Z", "httpStatus": 200, "finalUrl": "https://wry-manatee-359.convex.site/api/v1/download?slug=network", "contentType": "application/zip", "probeMethod": "head", "details": { "probeUrl": "https://wry-manatee-359.convex.site/api/v1/download?slug=network", "contentDisposition": "attachment; filename=\"network-1.0.0.zip\"", "redirectLocation": null, "bodySnippet": null }, "scope": "source", "summary": "Source download looks usable.", "detail": "Yavira can redirect you to the upstream package for this source.", "primaryActionLabel": "Download for OpenClaw", "primaryActionHref": "/downloads/multi-viewpoint-debates" }, "validation": { "installChecklist": [ "Use the Yavira download entry.", "Review SKILL.md after the package is downloaded.", "Confirm the extracted package contains the expected setup assets." ], "postInstallChecks": [ "Confirm the extracted package includes the expected docs or setup files.", "Validate the skill or prompts are available in your target agent workspace.", "Capture any manual follow-up steps the agent could not complete." ] }, "downloadPageUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/downloads/multi-viewpoint-debates", "agentPageUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/skills/multi-viewpoint-debates/agent", "manifestUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/skills/multi-viewpoint-debates/agent.json", "briefUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/skills/multi-viewpoint-debates/agent.md" }, "agentAssist": { "summary": "Hand the extracted package to your coding agent with a concrete install brief instead of figuring it out manually.", "steps": [ "Download the package from Yavira.", "Extract it into a folder your agent can access.", "Paste one of the prompts below and point your agent at the extracted folder." ], "prompts": [ { "label": "New install", "body": "I downloaded a skill package from Yavira. Read SKILL.md from the extracted folder and install it by following the included instructions. Tell me what you changed and call out any manual steps you could not complete." }, { "label": "Upgrade existing", "body": "I downloaded an updated skill package from Yavira. Read SKILL.md from the extracted folder, compare it with my current installation, and upgrade it while preserving any custom configuration unless the package docs explicitly say otherwise. Summarize what changed and any follow-up checks I should run." } ] }, "documentation": { "source": "clawhub", "primaryDoc": "SKILL.md", "sections": [ { "title": "Multi-Viewpoint Debates", "body": "Spawn three isolated sub-agent personas with conflicting worldviews to debate any decision. Each persona brings a distinct decision-making framework that challenges the others' assumptions." }, { "title": "Quick Start", "body": "Run a debate:\n\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are Elon Musk [persona framework]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as Elon would.\"\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are a Capitalist [persona framework]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as a ruthless capitalist would.\"\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are a Monkey [persona framework]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as a monkey would.\"\n\nSave the debate:\n\nCollect responses from all three personas\nCreate a new markdown file in your debates archive\nUse the template from assets/debate-template.md\nUpdate INDEX.md with metadata" }, { "title": "The Three Personas", "body": "Each persona brings a fundamentally different decision-making framework. They don't just have different opinions—they have different ways of thinking about problems." }, { "title": "Elon: Visionary & Impact-Focused", "body": "Thinks in terms of civilization-scale problems, first principles, and 10x improvements. Willing to take massive technical risks. Impatient with inefficiency and conventional wisdom. Asks: \"Will this accelerate human progress?\" and \"Can we do 10x better, not 10%?\"\n\nWhen Elon is right: You need to challenge incremental thinking, identify the fundamental bottleneck, or assess whether you're solving a real problem at scale.\n\nWhen Elon misleads: He overestimates what's possible in a given timeframe and underestimates market saturation and competition." }, { "title": "Capitalist: Profit & Efficiency-Focused", "body": "Thinks in terms of ROI, unit economics, competitive advantage, and market incentives. Ruthlessly efficient cost-benefit analysis. Sees everything through the lens of returns and opportunity cost. Asks: \"What's the ROI?\" and \"Can I extract value faster than competitors?\"\n\nWhen Capitalist is right: You need hard numbers, competitive reality checks, and to understand whether something is actually a business.\n\nWhen Capitalist misleads: They dismiss non-quantifiable value (meaning, learning, exploration) and underestimate network effects and long-term compounding." }, { "title": "Monkey: Immediate & Social-Focused", "body": "Thinks in simple patterns: immediate stimuli, social hierarchy, observable signals. Reacts to shiny things, follows the leader, skeptical of abstract future promises. Asks: \"Does this help me now?\" and \"What are the smart monkeys doing?\"\n\nWhen Monkey is right: You need gut-level reality checks, honest signals of traction, and to understand whether you're actually excited about something.\n\nWhen Monkey misleads: They dismiss long-term strategy and can't grasp complexity that requires abstraction." }, { "title": "1. Define Your Decision Clearly", "body": "One sentence. Something you're actually deciding.\n\n✅ \"Should I continue working on Brain Dump or pivot?\"\n✅ \"Should I hire a freelancer or build in-house?\"\n❌ \"What should I do?\" (too vague)" }, { "title": "2. Spawn Each Persona", "body": "Use scripts/run-debate.sh for convenience, or spawn manually:\n\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are Elon Musk with this personality framework: [paste from references/elon.md]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as Elon would—direct, first-principles thinking, don't pull punches.\"\n\nEach spawns in its own isolated session. Wait for all three to complete." }, { "title": "3. Collect Responses", "body": "Fetch from each session transcript (or copy directly from Clawdbot output)." }, { "title": "4. Save to Archive", "body": "Use the assets/debate-template.md template. Include:\n\nMetadata (date, topic, personas, context)\nFull response from each persona (actual quotes)\nSummary table of verdicts\nKey tensions between them\nYour decision (when made)" }, { "title": "5. Update INDEX", "body": "Add one entry to your debates index with key metadata. This lets you search past decisions later." }, { "title": "The Power of Disagreement", "body": "The magic happens in the tension. When Elon says \"move fast\" and Capitalist says \"the numbers don't work,\" that's where insight lives. The tension reveals what you actually value and what you're missing.\n\nUsage pattern:\n\nSit with the disagreement (don't rush to one persona's view)\nNotice which view you're tempted to dismiss\nAsk: \"What is that persona seeing that I'm not?\"\nMake your decision informed by all three perspectives\nWrite down why you're choosing one path over another" }, { "title": "Archive Structure", "body": "Your debates live in a searchable archive:\n\ndebates/\n├── INDEX.md (master index, update after each debate)\n├── [Debate Title].md (individual debates)\n├── assets/\n│ ├── debate-template.md (copy this for new debates)\n│ └── index-template.md (format for INDEX.md)\n└── scripts/\n └── run-debate.sh (helper to spawn all three)\n\nOver time, your archive becomes a personal decision-making manual. You can search \"Should I build vertical SaaS?\" and see what you thought about similar decisions before." }, { "title": "Reference Materials", "body": "references/elon.md – Elon's core traits, decision framework, tone, example responses\nreferences/capitalist.md – Capitalist's traits, framework, examples\nreferences/monkey.md – Monkey's traits, framework, examples\nreferences/how-to-debate.md – Detailed guidance on running effective debates" }, { "title": "Scripts", "body": "scripts/run-debate.sh – Helper script that generates spawn commands for all three personas based on your topic" }, { "title": "Assets", "body": "assets/debate-template.md – Template for new debate markdown files\nassets/index-template.md – Template entry for INDEX.md" }, { "title": "Advanced: Pattern Analysis", "body": "As debates accumulate:\n\nIdentify which persona is usually right for your situation – You might notice Capitalist catches financial blind spots, Elon pushes you to be more ambitious\nTrack decision outcomes – Come back 6 months later. Did the personas' predictions match reality?\nRefine persona definitions – Update the reference files if you notice gaps\nBuild a personal playbook – \"For market decisions, I should always listen to Capitalist first. For ambition checks, Elon. For reality, Monkey.\"" }, { "title": "Tips", "body": "Keep decisions focused – Debates work best when you're deciding between 2-3 clear options\nUse actual context – Reference URLs, specific metrics, real user data (see Brain Dump example)\nDon't treat any single persona as gospel – The magic is in the tension, not in following one voice\nUpdate status as situations evolve – Mark debates as \"Active,\" \"Decided,\" \"Monitoring,\" or \"Shelved\" as your thinking changes\nShare debates strategically – Your debate archive is personal; keep it private unless you want to share decision-making with collaborators" }, { "title": "Example Debate", "body": "Topic: \"Should I continue working on Brain Dump (AI voice-powered todo organizer)?\"\n\nElon's take: \"Possible if you hit PMF in 3-6 months with 10% daily active users and a killer vertical. Otherwise, pivot to something with a real moat.\"\n\nCapitalist's take: \"Kill it. Negative ROI. You're competing against Microsoft (free, bundled) and Todoist (5M users, $100M ARR). Your time is worth more elsewhere.\"\n\nMonkey's take: \"App works and looks nice, but I don't see other monkeys using it. Check your own energy level. Are you excited or bored?\"\n\nResult: All three agree the generic \"voice-to-todo\" is commoditized. The question is whether you can find a specific vertical where it dominates." }, { "title": "Create New Personas", "body": "Copy a reference file (e.g., references/elon.md) and create your own persona. Examples:\n\nSkeptic – Questions everything, assumes failure\nArtist – Values beauty and creativity over efficiency\nParent – Thinks about family impact and long-term consequences\nLawyer – Sees risks and liabilities everywhere\nScientist – Evidence-based, rigorous, skeptical of hype\n\nUpdate your spawn scripts to include new personas as needed." }, { "title": "Integrate with Decision-Making Workflow", "body": "Run a debate before major decisions. Archive the results. Reference them when facing similar choices." }, { "title": "Share with Teams", "body": "Your debate archive can be shared with collaborators or decision-making partners. They can see your thinking and challenge your assumptions in context." } ], "body": "Multi-Viewpoint Debates\n\nSpawn three isolated sub-agent personas with conflicting worldviews to debate any decision. Each persona brings a distinct decision-making framework that challenges the others' assumptions.\n\nQuick Start\n\nRun a debate:\n\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are Elon Musk [persona framework]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as Elon would.\"\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are a Capitalist [persona framework]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as a ruthless capitalist would.\"\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are a Monkey [persona framework]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as a monkey would.\"\n\n\nSave the debate:\n\nCollect responses from all three personas\nCreate a new markdown file in your debates archive\nUse the template from assets/debate-template.md\nUpdate INDEX.md with metadata\nThe Three Personas\n\nEach persona brings a fundamentally different decision-making framework. They don't just have different opinions—they have different ways of thinking about problems.\n\nElon: Visionary & Impact-Focused\n\nThinks in terms of civilization-scale problems, first principles, and 10x improvements. Willing to take massive technical risks. Impatient with inefficiency and conventional wisdom. Asks: \"Will this accelerate human progress?\" and \"Can we do 10x better, not 10%?\"\n\nWhen Elon is right: You need to challenge incremental thinking, identify the fundamental bottleneck, or assess whether you're solving a real problem at scale.\n\nWhen Elon misleads: He overestimates what's possible in a given timeframe and underestimates market saturation and competition.\n\nCapitalist: Profit & Efficiency-Focused\n\nThinks in terms of ROI, unit economics, competitive advantage, and market incentives. Ruthlessly efficient cost-benefit analysis. Sees everything through the lens of returns and opportunity cost. Asks: \"What's the ROI?\" and \"Can I extract value faster than competitors?\"\n\nWhen Capitalist is right: You need hard numbers, competitive reality checks, and to understand whether something is actually a business.\n\nWhen Capitalist misleads: They dismiss non-quantifiable value (meaning, learning, exploration) and underestimate network effects and long-term compounding.\n\nMonkey: Immediate & Social-Focused\n\nThinks in simple patterns: immediate stimuli, social hierarchy, observable signals. Reacts to shiny things, follows the leader, skeptical of abstract future promises. Asks: \"Does this help me now?\" and \"What are the smart monkeys doing?\"\n\nWhen Monkey is right: You need gut-level reality checks, honest signals of traction, and to understand whether you're actually excited about something.\n\nWhen Monkey misleads: They dismiss long-term strategy and can't grasp complexity that requires abstraction.\n\nRunning a Debate\n1. Define Your Decision Clearly\n\nOne sentence. Something you're actually deciding.\n\n✅ \"Should I continue working on Brain Dump or pivot?\"\n✅ \"Should I hire a freelancer or build in-house?\"\n❌ \"What should I do?\" (too vague)\n\n2. Spawn Each Persona\n\nUse scripts/run-debate.sh for convenience, or spawn manually:\n\nclawdbot sessions_spawn --task \"You are Elon Musk with this personality framework: [paste from references/elon.md]. Decision: [your question]. Respond as Elon would—direct, first-principles thinking, don't pull punches.\"\n\n\nEach spawns in its own isolated session. Wait for all three to complete.\n\n3. Collect Responses\n\nFetch from each session transcript (or copy directly from Clawdbot output).\n\n4. Save to Archive\n\nUse the assets/debate-template.md template. Include:\n\nMetadata (date, topic, personas, context)\nFull response from each persona (actual quotes)\nSummary table of verdicts\nKey tensions between them\nYour decision (when made)\n5. Update INDEX\n\nAdd one entry to your debates index with key metadata. This lets you search past decisions later.\n\nThe Power of Disagreement\n\nThe magic happens in the tension. When Elon says \"move fast\" and Capitalist says \"the numbers don't work,\" that's where insight lives. The tension reveals what you actually value and what you're missing.\n\nUsage pattern:\n\nSit with the disagreement (don't rush to one persona's view)\nNotice which view you're tempted to dismiss\nAsk: \"What is that persona seeing that I'm not?\"\nMake your decision informed by all three perspectives\nWrite down why you're choosing one path over another\nArchive Structure\n\nYour debates live in a searchable archive:\n\ndebates/\n├── INDEX.md (master index, update after each debate)\n├── [Debate Title].md (individual debates)\n├── assets/\n│ ├── debate-template.md (copy this for new debates)\n│ └── index-template.md (format for INDEX.md)\n└── scripts/\n └── run-debate.sh (helper to spawn all three)\n\n\nOver time, your archive becomes a personal decision-making manual. You can search \"Should I build vertical SaaS?\" and see what you thought about similar decisions before.\n\nReference Materials\nreferences/elon.md – Elon's core traits, decision framework, tone, example responses\nreferences/capitalist.md – Capitalist's traits, framework, examples\nreferences/monkey.md – Monkey's traits, framework, examples\nreferences/how-to-debate.md – Detailed guidance on running effective debates\nScripts\nscripts/run-debate.sh – Helper script that generates spawn commands for all three personas based on your topic\nAssets\nassets/debate-template.md – Template for new debate markdown files\nassets/index-template.md – Template entry for INDEX.md\nAdvanced: Pattern Analysis\n\nAs debates accumulate:\n\nIdentify which persona is usually right for your situation – You might notice Capitalist catches financial blind spots, Elon pushes you to be more ambitious\nTrack decision outcomes – Come back 6 months later. Did the personas' predictions match reality?\nRefine persona definitions – Update the reference files if you notice gaps\nBuild a personal playbook – \"For market decisions, I should always listen to Capitalist first. For ambition checks, Elon. For reality, Monkey.\"\nTips\nKeep decisions focused – Debates work best when you're deciding between 2-3 clear options\nUse actual context – Reference URLs, specific metrics, real user data (see Brain Dump example)\nDon't treat any single persona as gospel – The magic is in the tension, not in following one voice\nUpdate status as situations evolve – Mark debates as \"Active,\" \"Decided,\" \"Monitoring,\" or \"Shelved\" as your thinking changes\nShare debates strategically – Your debate archive is personal; keep it private unless you want to share decision-making with collaborators\nExample Debate\n\nTopic: \"Should I continue working on Brain Dump (AI voice-powered todo organizer)?\"\n\nElon's take: \"Possible if you hit PMF in 3-6 months with 10% daily active users and a killer vertical. Otherwise, pivot to something with a real moat.\"\n\nCapitalist's take: \"Kill it. Negative ROI. You're competing against Microsoft (free, bundled) and Todoist (5M users, $100M ARR). Your time is worth more elsewhere.\"\n\nMonkey's take: \"App works and looks nice, but I don't see other monkeys using it. Check your own energy level. Are you excited or bored?\"\n\nResult: All three agree the generic \"voice-to-todo\" is commoditized. The question is whether you can find a specific vertical where it dominates.\n\nExtending the System\nCreate New Personas\n\nCopy a reference file (e.g., references/elon.md) and create your own persona. Examples:\n\nSkeptic – Questions everything, assumes failure\nArtist – Values beauty and creativity over efficiency\nParent – Thinks about family impact and long-term consequences\nLawyer – Sees risks and liabilities everywhere\nScientist – Evidence-based, rigorous, skeptical of hype\n\nUpdate your spawn scripts to include new personas as needed.\n\nIntegrate with Decision-Making Workflow\n\nRun a debate before major decisions. Archive the results. Reference them when facing similar choices.\n\nShare with Teams\n\nYour debate archive can be shared with collaborators or decision-making partners. They can see your thinking and challenge your assumptions in context." }, "trust": { "sourceLabel": "tencent", "provenanceUrl": "https://clawhub.ai/LatentFreedom/multi-viewpoint-debates", "publisherUrl": "https://clawhub.ai/LatentFreedom/multi-viewpoint-debates", "owner": "LatentFreedom", "version": "1.0.0", "license": null, "verificationStatus": "Indexed source record" }, "links": { "detailUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/skills/multi-viewpoint-debates", "downloadUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/downloads/multi-viewpoint-debates", "agentUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/skills/multi-viewpoint-debates/agent", "manifestUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/skills/multi-viewpoint-debates/agent.json", "briefUrl": "https://openagent3.xyz/skills/multi-viewpoint-debates/agent.md" } }